“Have you talked to them about it?” It’s the question I wish someone had asked about me when I was a beginner surfer at Freshwater Beach, and it’s the one that gets a founder out of the middle of their team’s arguments. If every complaint in your business ends up on your desk, this is how to send it back where it belongs.
My surf nemesis
I once had a surf nemesis. He was a big guy, built like a rugby player, and nearly every time I paddled out at Freshwater Beach he was out to get me. My happy place had become an unhappy place. It peaked during the first COVID lockdown in 2020, and for a long time I had no idea what I’d done.
Surfing has rules, a bit like the rules of the road. The main one is simple: the surfer closest to where the wave breaks has right of way. If you take off in front of them, that’s called dropping in.
When I started, I didn’t know that rule existed. I was a beginner on a longboard. I couldn’t turn it much, but I could paddle fast, my arms going round like helicopter blades with spray everywhere. So I’d catch waves early, then go straight across the path of better surfers. I was dropping in, and I had no idea. Somewhere along the way I must have dropped in on him, and he took a beginner’s mistake as an attack.
Threats don’t change anyone
Every time I tried to talk to him, it ended in a threat. That’s what happens in a team without trust: an honest mistake looks like an attack.
The angry surfers didn’t make me a better surfer. They just made me nervous. What changed me was much smaller. One day I asked some of the friendlier surfers, “Was I in the wrong?” They said yes, and told me why. That’s when I discovered I was the problem.
What The Five Dysfunctions of a Team says
Patrick Lencioni writes about this in his book, The Five Dysfunctions of a Team. On a strong team, the leader isn’t the only one holding people to account. The team holds each other to account, because letting down people you respect hurts more than disappointing the boss.
In a lot of small businesses, it works the other way round. I spoke with a founder who ran a small online business with a team of five. He ran a weekly team meeting for months to keep everyone on track, and the team actually loved it. But he hated it so much that he started dreading Mondays, so he stopped. Then days went by without anyone checking in, and the team lost energy.
When you’re the only one holding the line, accountability lasts as long as your energy does.
Three ways to get your team holding each other to account
- First, say the rules out loud. Nobody told me about dropping in. Your team can’t hold each other to a standard nobody has stated. Write down what good looks like, who owns what, and what needs to be delivered by when.
- Second, let people argue before a decision, not after. People can disagree and still commit once they’ve been heard. And make it safe to call out a problem, or a drop-in, early, before it turns into a feud.
- Third, ask one question. When someone comes to you complaining about a teammate, ask them: “Have you talked to them about it?” If they haven’t, send them back to do it. Every complaint you take on becomes your problem. Every one you send back stays with the people who can fix it.
Party waves
These days at Freshwater, I’m one of the friendly ones. When a small wave comes through, I’ll shout “party wave” and call the others on, and when a beginner drops in, I let them know the rule. My nemesis? With enough time and good behaviour, it seems to have been forgotten.
A team that tells each other the truth doesn’t need you to be the referee. So when did someone on your team last hold a teammate to account without you in the room?
If this one landed, three more worth your time: How To Turn A Dysfunctional Team Into A High-performing One | Why Your Team Brings You Every Problem, and How To Fix It | How To Lead Tough Conversations With Calm And Clarity
Start here: virtualdoo.com/products



